NEIL YOUNG – ” The Geffen Albums “

Posted: December 30, 2021 in MUSIC
See the source image

Over the years, Neil Young has gained a reputation for flitting from genre to genre.  However during the height of his success and popularity, this reputation was a bit of an exaggeration.  Most artists are known for having a singular distinctive sound; Neil Young, by contrast, was known for having two.  There is the country-tinged, acoustic-based, singer-songwriter sound frequently recorded with his backing band The Stray Gators on albums like “Harvest”.  And there is the proto-grunge, electric-based, sloppy rock & roll sound frequently recorded with his backing band Crazy Horse on albums like “Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere”. Like some of the grunge musicians he went on to inspire, Neil Young has a conflicted relationship with his own success. “”Heart of Gold’ put me in the middle of the road. Traveling there soon became a bore, so I headed for the ditch,” he wrote in the liner notes to 1977’s greatest-hits album, “Decade“. “A rougher ride but I saw more interesting people there.”

For the first ten years of his solo career Neil Young seemed happy and was doing well commercially simply by alternating between these two poles of his musical personality.  However, by the early eighties things had started to run out of gas for Neil.  His last two albums, 1980’s “Hawks & Doves” (an acoustic album) and 1981’s “Re·ac·tor” (an electric album) had not done so well and Neil left his long time label, Reprise for the untested waters of Geffen Records.  That’s where Neil’s reputation for experimentation begins and mostly stays – at Geffen Records.

The three albums Young released after “Heart Of Gold” contain some of the darkest and most visceral songs he ever laid to tape, but the 80s were a rough ride for entirely different reasons, when Young released his string of experimental albums for his new label Geffen Records.

In 1982, Young left his long time label, Reprise, to join his friend David Geffen’s new, eponymous imprint. The five albums he released for Geffen are easily the most experimental in his discography, with Young swerving from one musical lane to the next. Yet there’s a lot to appreciate across on these records, and their best moments serve as a reminder that while Young could always be unpredictable in the studio, he was never uninspired.

See the source image

“Trans” (1982)

While he might have seen the new record label as chance to stretch out and experiment with something new, the first album that Young brought to the record company was in fact fairly “characteristic” of Neil Young.  It was recorded in Hawaii and entitled “Island In The Sun”.  Neil has described this album as “a tropical thing all about sailing, ancient civilizations, islands and water.”  No one has been really specific about why Geffen rejected “Island In The Sun”, but I like to think that Geffen encouraged Neil to try something new and different, words that David Geffen would later regret. 

So Neil recorded 6 songs in this neo-futuristic mould and mixed with three leftovers from “Island In The Sun” and submitted this record to Geffen.

You could write a short book unpacking “Trans” backstory, but, in brief: Young’s son Ben was born with cerebral palsy, which left him unable to speak (among other things) and required him to spend nearly two years in therapy. Intrigued by the idea that his son could learn to communicate through technology – and inspired by bands like Devo and Kraftwerk – Young threw himself into a synthetic new sound, laying Synclavier overdubs on top of rock instrumentation and singing through a vocoder to symbolise his attempts to communicate with his son. The result is an album that sounds at once glossy and corroded, like a clear topcoat applied to a machine that has already rusted through.

Perhaps part of the problem is that as much as Neil loved this sound, he hadn’t written enough material to record in this style.  This would explain why Neil decided to re-record the Buffalo Springfield song “Mr. Soul” in this style.  It also seems like Neil was hesitant to record anything in this style that wasn’t specifically written for this new futuristic genre.  All of the new songs revolve around computers and robots and other sci-fi nonsense.  

Initially seen as a misstep at the time of its release, on 29th December 1982, “Trans” has aged beautifully so much so that it no longer makes sense to call it an “underrated gem”. Its more raucous cuts, like “We R In Control” and “Computer Cowboy (AKA Syscrusher),” offer the same satisfying crunch as any Crazy Horse jam, while another song, “Sample And Hold,” splits the difference between Crazy Horse and Daft Punk. Even through a vocoder, Young’s plaintive tenor loses none of its emotive power, expressing the yearning at the heart of “Transformer Man” and “Mr. Soul.”

On the whole, “Trans” is an album about how technology was going to change – and has changed – the world we live in. But it’s “Little Thing Called Love” and “Hold Onto Your Love,” two of three holdovers from a scrapped project named “Island In The Sun“, that go back to Young’s therapy sessions with his son, as well as a theme he’s been writing about for his entire career: the power of love above all else.

See the source image

“Everybody’s Rockin” (1983)

While listeners and critics scratched their heads in response to “Trans“, the higher-ups at Geffen wrung their hands. In an attempt to get their musical maverick back on track, they stipulated that Young’s next release be a “rock’n’roll album”. Neil for his part, gave them a record that returned to his old ways for their second album together.  He even named the album “Old Ways“.  However, much like “Island In The Sun”, Geffen was not happy and rejected this initial version of “Old Ways”.  While Geffen had promised Neil artistic control, this was the second record of his that they had rejected, something that had never happened once at his old record label.  The original “Old Ways” album had a lot of country on it, and Geffen wanted Neil Young to record a rock & roll album.  In a streak of willful stubbornness and perversity, Neil took the three tracks from this album that hewed closer to the old-school rock & roll sound (“Wonderin’”, “Cry, Cry, Cry”, and “Mystery Train”) and recorded an entire record of early rockabilly and doo-wop styled oldies.  The original “Old Ways” also included a version of “That’s Alright Mama” so clearly this was a direction that Neil was starting to head in anyway, but once again Geffen was regret what they asked.

The album they got, “Everybody’s Rockin”, was in fact a pure rockabilly album, complete with the rich reverb and backing vocals that characterized the genre in the 50s, and was cut in a little over a month with a group of players Young christened his band The Shocking Pinks.

Taken on its own terms, “Everybody’s Rockin’ is a fun blast from the past. Young faithfully recreates the rockabilly sound, and songs like the title track and “Kinda Fonda Wanda” would sound right at home on a jukebox. Young even went to the trouble of slicking his hair back into a pompadour for the cover photo and convening a genuine rockabilly band in The Shocking Pinks to back him up.  While there are ten total tracks on the album, keeping with period’s aesthetic of sub-three minute pop songs, the album ended up being one of the shortest of Neil’s career, coming in at 25 minutes.  There were an additional two songs planned for this release, “Get Gone” and “Don’t Take Your Love Away From Me” that were planned for this album, however Geffen got tired of Young’s shenanigans and cancelled the recording sessions. He and The Shocking Pinks also try their hand at a few covers – most notably Junior Parker’s “Mystery Train,” a song made famous by the original king of rock’n’roll, Elvis Presley.

Furthermore relations between Neil and his record company were going to be thorny at best until he was able to fulfill his contract and leave the label.

See the source image

“Old Ways” (1985)

The first thing Neil released on Geffen post-lawsuit was a revamped version of “Old Ways“.  Having used the less country sounding tracks for “Everybody’s Rockin” Neil decided to go full-bore into the country thing.  While this I’m sure upset the suits at Geffen, unlike the electro-synth of “Trans” or the rockabilly of “Everybody’s Rockin’ this was not nearly as much of a stretch for Neil.  Most of Neil’s acoustic albums had a touch of country to them, getting more pronounced over time.  1972’s “Harvest” was more of a straight ahead folk-styled singer-songwriter record, but his 1978 acoustic album “Comes A Time” flirted very heavily with the Nashville sound.   In addition the new songs that were recorded in 1977 as “Chrome Dreams” mutated into “American Stars ‘n Bars” were also very country-ish.  These tracks all ended up on side one of “American Stars ‘n Bars“, while side two of 1980’s “Hawks & Doves” is another half-album of country-tinged acoustic rock.  So this was not totally new territory that Neil was venturing into here, even if he was delving farther than before.  Young had a version of “Old Ways” ready to go in 1983 but was forced to put it on hold in favour of his “rock’n’roll album”. He returned to the studio to make some adjustments to the record, adding some new songs and bringing in country music legends Waylon Jennings and Willie Nelson to sing along, before finally releasing the album on 12th August 1985.

While Young had recorded several albums in a country-rock style before (“Harvest, Comes A Time, Hawks & Doves”), “Old Ways” was (and remains) his furthest foray into pure country music – and he didn’t do it halfway, embellishing these songs with fiddles and even a Jew’s harp (the bouncy instrument you hear on “Get Back To The Country.”

As with “Everybody’s Rockin’, the most compelling reason to listen to “Old Ways” is to hear Young throw himself headlong into a genre he isn’t known for. There are a few moments where he wanders a bit too far into melodramatic, string-laden territory, but then there are also some truly lovely moments, like “Are There Any More Real Cowboys?,” an ode to “country families” and the working men who support them (“Not the one/That’s snorting cocaine/When the honky-tonks all closed/But the one/That prays for more rain”), and “Bound For Glory,” in which two lonely travellers find love on the road. Let’s put it this way: if you’ve got a friend who loves country music and has never heard Neil Young, this wouldn’t be a bad introduction.

See the source image

“Landing On Water” (1986)

Released on July 28th 1986, “Landing On Water” sounds a little like Neil returning to the electronic sound of “Trans” only without the vocoder this time.  While his previous three records all had very distinct and defined tropes that Neil was striving for, it’s hard to say even what he was trying to do with “Landing On Water“.  On one hand, maybe he was trying to craft a very contemporary and pop sounding album.  

But maybe It’s hard to say what exactly Young was trying to accomplish with “Landing On Water“, which came out less than a year after “Old Ways”, on 21st July 1986. On one hand, it’s the most rock-oriented album that he released on Geffen, rocking even harder than his 1987 reunion with Crazy Horse, “Life”. But on the other hand, it sometimes feels more robotic and compressed than “Trans”.

That said, “Landing On Water” has its highlights. “Hippie Dream” is a bitter swipe at – you guessed it – hippie idealism, reserving some of Young’s sharpest barbs for former CSNY bandmate David Crosby (“Another flower child/Goes to seed”). “Touch The Night” is an anthemic, crushing number that ends with a guitar solo so thrilling that even the production does little to dampen it. And on “Pressure,” Young hits the same cold, brittle grooves that Joy Division and Gang Of Four used to build post-punk. It would be fascinating to hear a modern rock band try to bring “Landing On Water’s” retro-futuristic sound into the present.

See the source image

Life (1987)

Neil Young’s final album for Geffen, “Life”, is routinely ignored as one would assume it’s just another failed experiment like the other four Geffen releases.  Truth is “Life” is pretty much just “characteristic” Neil Young.  While the cover depicts a man in prison with the scrawled five chalk marks on the wall can be seen to represent the five albums that Neil owed Geffen in his contract, this album feels a little like Neil finally giving Geffen what they want: a typical Neil Young record.  Neil even reunited with Crazy Horse on this album, recording it the same way they did “Rust Never Sleeps” in 1979.  Instead of simply recording the songs in the studio, Neil and Crazy Horse played the new song live in front of an audience and then went back and took the audience noises off of the record to create the illusion of a new studio album. Young had little to do with his trusty backing band, Crazy Horse, in the 80s. They appeared on some parts of “Trans“, while many of the songs that would appear on “Landing On Water” were first attempted, unsuccessfully, with the group in 1984. In late 1986, Young brought the Horse on tour again, during which they performed several new songs live. Those songs would form the bulk of “Life”, released on 6th July 1987 as Young’s final album for Geffen, and his first with Crazy Horse since 1979’s “Rust Never Sleeps“.

After four albums of genre experiments, “Life” marked Young’s return to no-nonsense rock. All but two songs were recorded in an amphitheater, and it sounds like it. The material is stronger, too, starting with “Mideast Vacation” and “Long Walk Home,” two sobering tracks that address America’s hawkish approach to foreign policy as well as its human cost.

“Life” has some majestic slow-burners, such as “Inca Queen” and “When Your Lonely Heart Breaks,” and some fierce barnburners like “Around The World” and the pointed “Prisoners Of Rock’n’Roll,” all of which transcend their 80s production and stand as some of the best songs Young wrote that decade. It’s hard to say if anyone in the audience might recognize these songs if Young were to perform them live today, but it would be thrilling to see him dust them off.  “Life” is easily the least memorable or interesting of the Geffen years.  However it did accomplish Neil’s goal of fulfilling his contract allowing him to run back to the accepting arms of his old record company, Reprise Records.

Neil Young returned to Reprise Records in late 1987, but he wasn’t quite finished with the genre-hopping experimentation. In 1988, he released “This Note’s For You”, in which he put together a new band, The Bluenotes (complete with a horn section), and tried his hand at blues-rock. He wasn’t finished with being an anti-commercial crank, either. That album’s title track is a vicious takedown of corporate-friendly artists who are all too happy to sign their songs over to advertisers. The song’s music video featured a Michael Jackson lookalike with burning hair, which drove Jackson to threaten legal action.

While it would be difficult to argue that Neil Young’s Geffen years saw him at his artistic peak, one can be certain that he was making exactly the kind of music he wanted to. When the label sued him for making music that was “uncharacteristic of [his] previous recordings”, they had lost sight of what made him a rock legend: his refusal to rest on his artistic laurels, and his willingness to chase his muse down every road it leads him. No doubt Neil Young would have made it easier on himself if he’d been willing to pursue a more commercially viable path in the interest of selling more records, but he wouldn’t be Neil Young if he did.

thanks Detours and Outliers for some words

When Geffen sued Neil Young for not being “commercial”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.